Tuesday, September 20, 2005

Weighing Roberts

Well, I've retreated a little bit from my wholehearted endorsement of Roberts, but I don't know that I would vote against him

As earlier analysis in the Times has allowed, it seems that Robert's judicial philosophy is somewhere between a Thomas/Bork/Scalia and a Renquist. He does not believe in a "general" right to privacy (a la Thomas/Bork), but he does believe, unlike Scalia, that the constitition can "evolve" to include modern concepts of morality and new technologies. That puts him somewhere between very and extremely conservative.

I certainly would never *endorse* someone of this temperment. I personally believe in the Kennedian approach of looking at universal (i.e., international) human values and in respecting precidents in social rights, which would argue for a general privacy right.

But I say that the question is this: does a President have the right to nominate someone of his own judicial philosophy, as long as that philosophy is not TOO far outside the mainstream? I would certainly want a Democratic president to be able to nominate someone with clear liberal views. Roberts, it seems to me, is just inside the line of being within the conservative mainstream. And I find his ability to reason and change his opinion (however obtuse it may be) reassuring. So - while I have more misgivings than before - if it were me, I would still vote to confirm.


Anonymous said...

Hi, I was just blog surfing and found you! If you are interested, go see my weird ebay pulse auctions site. It isn't anything special but you may still find something to entertain you.

Anonymous said...

Blogs: A Global Conversation
James Torio has written an outstanding paper for people who have a basic understanding of blogs, but hunger to know more.
Great blog! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!

I have a Cash Advance Payday Loan site. It pretty much covers Cash Advance Payday Loan related stuff.
Come & check it out if you get time. :-)

Dr. X said...

Great job! Another decent payday loan site to add to my list! Hope you don't mind I leave mine here,
same day payday loan